Facebook Pixel Code
CALL 24/7 (615) 244-4325 ¿Habla Español?
by Michael Ponce | April 26, 2013

crutches_thumbThe Supreme Court of Tennessee ruled last month in favor of an on-call surgical technician who was injured while driving home after assisting with an emergency surgery at a Tennessee hospital. According to the court, the injured worker is eligible for workers’ compensation benefits because she falls within an exception to the rule under the TN Workers’ Compensation Act that prohibits compensation when the employee is injured while traveling to or from work. If you have suffered injuries in a workplace accident in Tennessee, contact our reputable attorneys at Michael D. Ponce & Associates to discuss your legal options. You may be entitled to workers’ comp benefits for your injuries and medical expenses, which our experienced lawyers can help you pursue.

TN Worker Injured While Driving Home From Work

Before her injury, Tina Shannon was a surgical technician at the Roane Medical Center in Harriman, Tennessee, where she worked a regular schedule from 7:00am to 3:00pm, Monday through Friday, and also covered on-call shifts on a rotating basis. On April 19, 2010, Shannon was still on call as she returned home after assisting with emergency surgery, and was involved in a car accident that took place when another driver crossed over the center line and into the path of her vehicle. As a result of her car accident injuries, Shannon missed 37 weeks of work, and she filed a suit seeking workers’ compensation benefits for her medical expenses and loss of income.

Trial Court Denies Workers’ Compensation Benefits

Shannon’s employer denied compensability for her injuries and argued that the worker was injured in a car accident, not in the course and scope of her employment as required under Tennessee workers’ compensation laws. In Tennessee, an employee injury giving rise to a workers’ compensation claim must arise out of and occur in the “course of employment.” The general rule is that a worker is not acting within the course of employment while traveling to and from work, unless the injury occurs on the employer’s premises. As a result, the trial court found in favor of the employer and denied Shannon workers’ compensation benefits, maintaining that an injury sustained while traveling to or from a place of employment was not compensable, despite Shannon’s on-call status.

Contact Our Qualified Attorneys for Legal Help

Upon learning of the trial court’s decision, Shannon appealed her case to the Supreme Court, which ruled that courts should consider the individual circumstances when determining whether the “coming and going rule” applies to an on-call worker. Looking at the totality of circumstances in Tina Shannon’s case, the Supreme Court found that Shannon satisfied the key elements for the exception to the “coming and going rule,” which rendered her eligible for workers’ compensation benefits. If you have been injured in an on-the-job accident in Tennessee, or if you lost a loved one in a fatal accident, consult our qualified lawyers at Michael D. Ponce & Associates for legal help. With our attorneys on your side, you can pursue the workers’ compensation benefits you are entitled to.

Source: http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e9974e60-702f-45f2-a09f-22a001d4fdf3

Free Case Review

Case Evaluation

"*" indicates required fields

MM slash DD slash YYYY

No Fee Guarantee

Our Reviews

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    As a Non-Tennessee resident, I selected Ponce Law after reading the reviews. You guys were spot on. This firm has some of the nicest, knowledgeable and easiest lawyers and staff to work with. I was amazed and very pleased with their diligence and work ethic! Even if I was worried about something and called for advice, they were quick to respond and answered my questions. I will highly recommend this firm.

    Terrence Harris 5 months ago
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Ponce Law Firm, has been the best experience for both of my children. Attorney helped me through all the process in a very timely profesional way. The Staff has been by far the best! I highly recommend this law firm.

    Ailed Martinez 5 months ago
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Always very professional. When we first called we had no idea if we even had a case, they told us we did. And even though the resolution took a little bit longer than expected, the wait was worth it. They get results and I really appreciated that they consistently gave me updates on the status of my case without me even asking. Thank you Ponce Law!

    Karla Drumm 3 months ago
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Everyone at Ponce law is extremely helpful. Cheyenne went above and beyond to help us. We got an amazing outcome with our settlement and the whole process was easier than we had ever expected. We got everything we asked for and more.

    Ashley Brossman 2 weeks ago
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    I had a really good experience with Ponce Law. I couldn't be more satisfied with my case. My settlement was satisfactory as well. I had a really complicated situation either my property damage and Ponce Law helped me work through all of it. Thanks so much!!

    Soraksa Touch 2 months ago
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Have you ever been caught between a Hyundai and a hard place? I have, Ponce Law was a call away and helped me through the entire process. Very friendly staff who explained every step of the process to me and made sure I understood what was going on. When I got injured I didn't know what to do but I'm glad I put in a call to Ponce Law.

    matt kenney a month ago


  • Block Image

    I was driving down I-40 when I got hit by another car. I called Michael Ponce because I wanted an attorney right here in Nashville. As soon as I called, I knew I made the right decision, and Ponce Law got me the money I needed to get back on my feet. I highly recommend Ponce Law!

    – Rick

    View More Testimonials

  • Block Image

    After my car accident, I wasn’t sure if I needed an attorney. I called Ponce Law for a free consultation. I’m so glad I made the call. I wanted a local attorney, and from the first call, to when my case was settled, I felt heard, valued, and taken care of.

    – ShaErica

    View More Testimonials

  • Block Image

    I was on I-40 coming into Nashville and a car ran into the back of me. The accident was serious, and I needed surgery. I did ask an attorney friend of mine whom I should call, and he said call Ponce Law. The folks at Ponce Law were outstanding and got us a large settlement.

    – Alex

    View More Testimonials

Ponce Law Awards & Recognition

Recent Blog Posts

View All Blog Posts

Ponce Law